King of Thorn – When the Sleeping Witch Awakens

King of Thorn / Ibara no Oh anime filmKing of Thorn (Ibara no Oh in Japanese) is a well-produced movie. It in many respects didn’t remind me of anime (series), but of western films. The plot in particular, which is a death-game meeting a mindscape film.

At a pretty early stage, I saw resemblance to the 2009 film Pandorum, and also to 1997’s Cube. Later on they actually reveal some of those similarities, at least to Cube aren’t superficial, when Alice speaks of how the whole way the event had been orchestrated was so specific people would survive, so Kasumi could make it out – the dangerous criminal, the leader-cop, the nurse who takes care of the helpless oracle (the child), and of course, cannon fodder, along with someone who possesses internal knowledge to get them started on their journey.

(This is a “Things I Like” post. It’s slightly more “reviewy” than usual, touching on the themes and production, rather than exploring them in-depth. The 2nd half of this piece tries to explain the ending, the “mystery”, and also elaborate on character-motivations. Full-film spoilers ahead.)

It’s apparent almost from the first moment that this film is more than a bit of a “mindscape” film, where it’s hard to tell apart what’s real and what’s imagined, and who’s hiding what. The child who speaks of monsters from his game comes not long after a line that no one that had watched such movies or much anime for some time could ignore: They ask the owner of the place whether they dream during their cryostasis, and the answer is that the system manipulates their brains’ electrical currents, meaning it can create false visions and dreams, and then they enter sleeping pods of the sort you see in The Matrix. I even took a note of what a big “line” it is, of how much of a tell it actually is.

It all added up to me questioning whether they are awake or still dreaming within the film, and if they’re dreaming, which character is the one dreaming it is. They touched on it nicely in the end, when Marco died, and he said that our world is the dream of another entity. The concept of the world being the dream of God or the Earth itself is nothing new, but the “Is this us dreaming the world, or the world dreaming us?” moment related quite well to the rest of the film.

Dreams, and wishes. But the ending wasn’t the real point of the film, nor was it the “plot”, as much as it was the journey of self-discovery, seeing the vistas born from our minds, seeing the results of our wishes. Wishing to live against all external threats, wishing to win against the insidious enemy that is despair.

It was a beautiful movie, with a good musical score. It was well-acted. The symbolism and constant references to “sleeping beauty” were a nice touch, even if they didn’t actually mean anything. But should they have had any meaning? They meant something to the characters. The fables and games and everything are just a roadmap for them to find their way in this confusing world, and even if there’s no deeper meaning, then perhaps one isn’t necessary.

strong 7/10. One that felt somewhat heavy. I truly felt like I was watching a film, rather than some light episodes strung together.

An Explanation of the Ending and Who’s Who:

King of Thorn / Ibara no Oh anime filmNote: The following section for the most part only makes sense if you’ve actually watched the film, as most of my posts are actually discussions assuming you’ve done so.
But just in case, in the end of the film our heroine reaches the “Cradle”, only to discover her twin sister is the one who had created all these thorns, and that this power to shape reality comes from aliens. We then find out that the “heroine” is actually a fake created, after one sister had accidentally killed the other, trying to die with her rather than let one of them survive, alone.

Now, here’s something that is interesting. Who lives? Who died? Of course, both the original Kasumi and Shizuku died, and a created “Kasumi” survived. That’s not really up for discussion, right? But, who was Sleeping Beauty? Who was the rampaging one? They kept calling her, because if the girl we all had access to was “Kasumi”.

But then we saw that the girl in the tower had a scar on her hand, while fake girl didn’t. Girl in tower was Kasumi. Alternative girl was “Shizuku”. Wait, why? Kasumi wanted to die, Shizuku ended up dying instead of her. Kasumi wanted her sister to come back more than anything else, so she recreated Shizuku. The Shizuku she created mostly a shell though. Now Real-Kasumi had to think of how she could get her beloved sister to live, while she herself wanted to die. The irony is that only Kasumi could survive, so Real-Kasumi put Alternative-Shizuku into Alice, and had her become “Kasumi”, so she could live.

How did Alternative-Shizuku become Fake-Kasumi? Here we go back to the all-important question about dreams. Alice had taken a snapshot of each of the characters’ personalities. Alice and Kasumi-in-the-tower had put Alternative-Shizuku into the capsule, and imprinted Real-Kasumi’s memories into her.

But here we got into this tangled yarn of thorny vines. Kasumi wanted Shizuku to live. Real-Kasumi created Alternative-Shizuku and made her think she’s Real-Shizuku so she’d manage to get out, and orchestrated everything. But with Real-Kasumi’s memories, Alternative-Shizuku was sure Shizuku is trapped in the tower, so threw away the gift she had been given in order to try and save Shizuku. And so the roles had been reversed, with Shizuku, who is the Sleeping Beauty, mentally, and with regards to knowing the truth, trying to save The Prince, who had woken her up, given her another life, and then woke her up from the Cryostasis.

All the thorns had two reasons. First, Real-Kasumi had twin desires: The first was saving Shizuku, so she tried to bar the way to her, so Alternative-Kasumi will not learn the truth. Second, she did not wish to break away from Shizuku, so aside from creating another alternative, a part of her tried to lock her in. But here’s Real-Kasumi’s other true wish. She wished to die. She tried to kill herself for the sake of Shizuku twice, but when it boils down to it, she wanted to die. Having essentially killed Shizuku in her second suicide attempt, she was filled with mad grief and self-hatred, manifesting in the birthing of monsters, and lashing out at the world, while trying to lock herself up in her castle.

Real-Kasumi saw herself as the witch, and so she had cursed herself, to lock herself away from the world, even as she tried to destroy the world that had been so unkind to her, taking away her parents and sister.

11 comments on “King of Thorn – When the Sleeping Witch Awakens

  1. I disagree with your assessment of the conclusion. Go back and watch the scene where Kasumi tries to throw herself and Shizuku off the cliff. When the surviving girl stands up, she starts saying “Kasumi, where are you? Kasumi!!” If Kasumi was the one who survived the double suicide attempt, why would she scream her own name? I know Kasumi was apparently the one on the table in the chamber at the end….but how this happened is beyond me, unless perhaps the english dub team made an error and mixed up the twins names during that scene? That is all that would make sense to me….because the flashback clearly shows that Shizuku is the one that survived the cliff scene. What are your thoughts?

    • Guy says:

      First, I only watched the subbed version, not the dubbed, so if the dub made a mistake, I don’t know.

      Second, the premise of this whole thing is that the trauma made the sister who survive immediately assume her sister’s identity over guilt over her death. So she’s shouting her own name because she adopted her now deceased sister’s identity.

      • tcdd says:

        I have to agree with Charles here. Go and watch again ;-)
        Anyway, quite different from the manga, yet I don’t find the changes destructive. I love it.

      • Trex says:

        Thanks, Though your analysis has helped a lot to understand the plot, I do agree with Charles that Kazumi was the one that died throwing herself off the cliff. She is the one laying dead on the bed of thorns (only kazumi has a scar on her hand from her first attempted suicide). Shizuku could not bear the death of her sister and while getting mad, started emanating the thorns. As a consequence, Dr. Vega saw her potential and decided to experiment on her. Consciously or unconsciously, Shizuku wanted her sister back and created “the alternative kazumi”, main character of the movie. She then hacked into Alice and used Alice to transfer her memories into alternative kazumi and programming the other characters… The real Shizuku has completely transformed her body into thorns – her flesh body does not exist anymore. She eventually dies with her castle of thorns. However, I still have doubts about the monsters – where they manifestations of Tim’s imagination ? Was Dr. Vega a real person? Were all the other characters real people programmed by Alice, or emanations of Shizuku as well ?…

        • Zee says:

          My take on it is that knowledge of the monsters was programmed by Alice into Tim, who related it to his games, and that’s how he recognized them all.

        • Dan Shanahan says:

          Okay. I think I’ve cracked it, and it’s so much simpler than we’re all trying to make it.
          This film confused the shit out of me so many times, but now it’s finally hit me, and it’s so simple.
          Shizuku and Kasumi are on the cliff, they fall, Kasumi died.
          Shizuku then awakens here powers and get’s taken in for testing.
          Once in control of her powers, Shizuku uses her vines to recover the body of Kasumi (The real one, the one that fell and died)
          As she is dead, Shizuku creates the alternative, (The version we follow and without the scar on her wrist)

          Shizuku becomes enveloped by Medusa and becomes the thorn being that restrains the Alternative Kasumi, Alternative Kasumi breaks free and see the body of the real Kasumi laying on the bed.

          As for when she was asleep and when she was awake, which memories were real and which were implanted, fucked if I know, But I think this solves the big question.

      • Zee says:

        She did not realize her sister was dead until looking over the cliff. Why would she assume her sister’s identity due to trauma… when the trauma wouldn’t hit until after she saw she was dead?

        The way I believe it to be, as others here have also said, it was Shizuku’s trauma that created the thorns and monsters, and she made an alternate of herself that became the new Kasumi (which is why new Kasumi doesn’t have a scar, because she’s actually replica of Shizuku’s body).

  2. GUY2 says:

    I feel as if first that Shizuku did survive the double suicide second that when she split in 2 one became the false Kasumi the other half became one with the thorns like this alternate being . Third the body on the table is the dead body of the real Kasumi

  3. Evie says:

    Interesting take on it… but it doesn’t add up. If Shizuku had died Kasumi would have just jumped, that was her goal in the first place. Kasumi died, and shizuku was the fake Kasumi. Whether Shizuku’s mind is the one that switched it or if Alice did it to protect her, Shizuku thought she was Kasumi and that’s why she didn’t have the scar and why her real body was nowhere to be found. If you pay attention you’ll notice that Alice’s body never changed, everything around her did. Also all the creatures made weren’t sentient, they were instinct based (thus human’s might be impossible). later we see that Alice could have had access to shizuku’s mind/creations when she is tormenting Marco with an image of his sister, when in reality she is manipulating the vines.

    The ending scene you realize that ‘Kasumi’ isn’t a medusa creation because she isn’t petrifying due to lack of creator’s consciousness. That can only mean she is shizuku (cause the one in the tower had the scar).

  4. J says:

    The other one must stay sleeping forever. So that the other can live forever.

  5. Ashitosh Kamble says:

    I also thinking similar. But as we know doctor says Alice can manipulate thought stream to make cryogenic subject dream. So what if all this was a dream to make wishes of both girls true. One wanted to die, because she think if se die her sister will be chosen instead or she just be free. And second sister wanted to keep first sister alive, as such she make a impossible wish that they will meet after first sister wakes-up. But which is almost impossible. So Alice made all a story to makes everyone’s wish come true. But for that first sister who chosen for cryogenesis should sleep forever(Hence the sleeping beauty) to see a dream where any and every ting is possible.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.