This is the first of a series of manga reviews by yours truly. I’ll be concentrating on off-the-wall stuff that I happen to like, and largely avoiding the really popular stuff that other people have already covered extensively elsewhere. I mostly buy my manga in the original Japanese (at the local Kinokuniya), and many of the titles I’ll be reviewing–including this first one–aren’t yet available in English.
Title: ヤンデレ彼女 (“Yandere Girlfriend”)
Mangaka: 忍 (Shinobi)
Publisher: Square Enix (GanGan Comics JOKER)
Price: ¥476 (US$7.55 at Kinokuniya U.S.A.)
Publication Date: August 22, 2009
Page Count: 144
Yandere Kanojo Cover
Yandere Kanojo is a gag manga with a very direct, straightforward style. It stars Reina Ryuuzaki and Manabu Tanaka. Reina is the leader of the female delinquents in her school, and Tanaka is a diligent but otherwise unremarkable student. “Yandere” normally refers to a girl who’s sick and twisted (from yanderu/病んでる) but has a flustered, lovestruck, sweet side (deredere/デレデレ). It’s a scarier variant of the tsundere thing that’s become so trendy. Yandere Kanojo doesn’t have a yandere character; instead, the “yan” in the title comes from Yankii (a female delinquent). Reina is this peculiar kind of “yandere,” a mean girl who can kick the crap out of anyone who crosses her path, but can be embarrassed and downright sweet when it comes to Tanaka.
So, like, I figured we could start dating and stuff…
In a typical manga storyline there would probably be a volume or two of them fumbling around trying to connect despite secondary characters with rivalries and jealousies going on. Here, Reina falls for Manabu, and while she’s trying to figure out what to do about it, it turns out that he likes her too. Problem solved! (Well, at first she assumes the letter he put in her locker was a challenge, but…) That’s not to say there’s no conflict in the story, but it tends to come more from Reina getting embarrassed or angry, or just falling back into her delinquent habits and slugging people.
After years of titles like Love Hina where an actual relationship is the end-point of the story rather than a beginning like in real life, I find it refreshing to read a manga where two lovers can earnestly connect. That said, while the comic is occasionally heartwarming, for the most part it’s about a bunch of really strange people. Tanaka is the most normal character by far, but his cute younger sister Mayami is a masochist who gets off on having Reina beat her up. Tanaka also has a rival in Tsubasa Shiratori, a “perfect” student who prizes his #1 spot in the school’s test rankings.
Mayami’s perfect vision of the future.
The format is an odd mixture of 4-panel comic strips and full-page strips (which typically have 5 or 6 panels), and while most of them have a gag at the end, they always cohere into an ongoing storyline, however absurd. This first volume catapults the reader through its take on a series of cliché manga high school tropes (athletics festival, studying for a big test, etc.). This could be a turn-off if you feel like you’ve read one high school manga too many, but seeing Reina trying to participate in a more normal school life despite her delinquent tendencies is the main appeal of Yandere Kanojo.
Does she even know how a 3-legged race actually works?
Shinobi’s art style seems like it has a little bit of shoujo manga influence, especially with Tanaka’s character design, but on the whole it’s expressive and fun despite not being the most technically proficient. Some panels—like where Reina wears cute, normal clothes for her first date with Manabu—are very well done, while in others the characters get badly out of model.
Her mom came up with this outfit for their first date…
Shinobi does a good job of cartoonishly portraying Reina’s over the top reactions, whether she’s blushing furiously, yelling at the top of her lungs, going crazy and attacking people or (as is often the case) all three at once. It lacks the stirring depictions of scenery in Azuma Kiyohiko’s recent works, but I was never confused about what was going on, and where the art could’ve been better, it didn’t particularly detract from the experience.
What *is* that?
I picked this manga up at Kinokuniya on a whim because I thought the title was amusing, and I voraciously read the whole thing in about a day. It’s not the very best manga out there, but it’s a heck of a lot of fun. In the final analysis, Yandere Kanojo is a little technically flawed, but in my opinion just too fun to pass up. I give it a 4 out of 5 rating.
Also, I love the visual table of contents, and I’m totally going to steal the idea for some of my own projects:
I have to admit this sounds rather interesting. Given my ever growing backlog of anime however, it might be some time before I ever read it -_-
“After years of titles like Love Hina where an actual relationship is the end-point of the story rather than a beginning like in real life”
Duuuh, Karekano ? Also, Love Roma, LoveCom, and Futari Ecchi, and thats without mentioning, oh i dont know, like EVERY SINGLE MODERN SHOUJO MANGA EVER ? By modern i mean the smutty ones, where main heroine usually is a whore of some kind.
I was referring more to what I’d been seeing in stuff I’ve read–which doesn’t normally include romance-oriented stories like the ones you’ve listed–rather than the totality of what’s out there. Still, I’ll have to check some of those out soon. :3
[…] Yandere Kanojo Vol. 1 Manga Review « Geekorner-Geekulture. geekorner.wordpress.com/2009/10/11/yandere-kanojo-vol-1-manga-review – view page – cached Home > Ewen's Corner, manga, review > Yandere Kanojo Vol. 1 Manga Review — From the page […]
The mixing of 4-koma and yet ongoing storyline sounded quite exciting. But it just hit me, isn’t that how most webcomics are? An endless string of 4-koma which add up to a storyline.
Still, this sounds interesting :)
Basically, but Yandere Kanojo does it more than most, to the point where you might wonder why he bothered to put it into 4-koma format.
Why do you think he did it?
Can one actually open the manga at a random page, read a “strip” and enjoy it, separated from the rest of the manga? That is, as much as one can enjoy a single strip of a long-running web-comic?
I would compare it to many webcomics; you could potentially enjoy a given strip in isolation, but ideally you’d want to be able to read the whole chapter.
WTH. This is the exact same basic premise as “Onidere” manga.
Or Yankee-kun to Megane-chan, for that matter (but there, the main character is a Yankee himself, though a lesser one.)
First time I see a different kind of manga. I mean, the drawnings are different from what Im used to.
The drawings are what I’d imagine Sayonara Zetsubo Sensei to look as as a manga, at least sometimes.
Sayonara Zetsubou-sensei was originally a manga. I have up to vol. 10 in Japanese, and I think they’re up to vol. 3 in English now. The anime is pretty closely based on the manga’s style, and while it gets kind of formulaic after a while, the art is really awesome the whole way through. Visually, it’s much more polished than Yandere Kanojo.
Since it’s a Square Enix title maybe we’ll see this in the Yen Plus anthology someday? It seems like something I’d try.
I would like to see that too. Spice and Wolf cover notwithstanding, I’ve been liking a whole lot of the stuff Yen Press has been doing, and I think Yandere Kanojo would be at home alongside stuff like Ichiroh and GA.
This looks interesting. The drawing style is not exactly my thing, but yandere sure are. I love yandere.
This manga is good at the beginning,I really enjoyed it.It is my opinion and not saying anything rude or trying to hurt the feeling of other readers .but I hate this manga from the moment where that,good for nothing,pervert,bastard president kissed reina on her chick ,from that moment I lost my all interest in this manga…I hate this manga,why how that president kissed her…😫😫😫😫😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭